BAA Summer Academy: Democratic Cultures Past and Present - Perspectives from Washington, DC
May 04, 2012 - May 05, 2012
Seminar at the GHI and American University
For two inspiring days during the week-long summer academy we were delighted to be able to enjoy the hospitality at the GHI. Our group of doctoral candidates affiliated with German and U.S. universities felt a warm welcome when Britta Waldschmidt-Nelson, deputy director at GHI, opened the first session on Monday morning. With the overall topic "Democratic Cultures Past and Present: Perspectives from Washington, D.C." the GHI was just the place to be at. Individual doctoral projects and three keynote lectures by Heike Paul, Werner Sollors and Maria Höhn were presented.
In her introductory keynote lecture Heike Paul dealt with the myth as a foundational moment in democratic cultures in her talk on "Memory Wars, Founders Chic and the Consumption of American Democracy." Paul indicated the continuities and changes in the canonical readings of specific texts by the Founding Fathers and elaborated on the "founders chic" by using Lauren Berlant's concept of the "intimate public sphere" (2004). Paul alluded to the fact that many authors of recent biographies of the founders, like David McCullough in his John Adams biography or Newt Gingrich in his historical novels, revisited the founders and presented them as founding gardeners, founding architects and cooks. Being in the kitchen with the Founding Fathers clearly indicates the consumption of the myth in a "sentimentalist country" again a term derived from Lauren Berlant (2009). Paul asked: "Who would argue about old recipes?" and stressed the "founders chic being part of the marketing of a nostalgic past."
The first round of work in progress presentations by the doctoral candidates strongly focused on contemporary politics: Sarah Nike Bernhard in her talk on "The Functionalization of Cultural Narration and Memory in Political Staging (Barack Obama's Presidential Campaign in 2008)" used the tropes of the American Adam and the family man to demonstrate the constructedness of male blackness in Obama's first campaign. Michael Oswald analysed interest group politics in his project "The Tea Party: A Social Movement or rather a Means of Post Democracy", referring to Colin Crouch's "Post-Democracy" (2004).
In the afternoon the second round of work in progress presentations covered a wider time span from Edmund Brown "The Unification of a Nation: How F.D.R. and Hitler Used Technology during Their Reign", to Stefanie Schäfer "Yankee Democracy? Canon Formation and the Struggle for Cultural Independence", and Sabrina Huettner "Politics of Dissent - The Theater of Naomi Wallace, Christopher Shinn and Tony Kushner." All three projects were already very well developed and indicated how and by whom a multiplicity of voices might be reduced by canon formation with the help of technical devices (the radio, but also in a broader sense the literary market) to transmit representative, but also biased interpretations of the state of democracy to the audience.
The evening keynote lecture by Werner Sollors unravelled a very intimate relationship "Hard on the Eyes: A Photographer and His Subject." Sollors began by showing the audience a photograph supposedly of a German child after the liberation of death camp Bergen-Belsen shot by British photojournalist George Rodger, who later became a founder member of Magnum photos, published in LIFE magazine exactly 67 years before the lecture on May 7, 1945. The boy really was Sieg Maandag, a Dutch Jewish child survivor of Bergen-Belsen. Sollors indicated with the false caption "Young German boy walking down dirt road lined with corpses of hundreds of prisoners who died of starvation near Bergen-Belsen extermination camp" the powerful rhetoric of the visual was further strengthened. And only after finding the real story behind the photograph the life-long traumatization of the subject and the photographer became the focus of Sollors captivating lecture.
On Tuesday morning the period after World War II, democratization processes in Germany, occupation and re-education were again at the center of Maria Höhn's talk titled "'We Will Never Go back to the Old Ways Again.' African American GIs, Germany and the Struggle for Civil Rights." The time African American GIs spent in Germany - most of them from the segregated Deep South of the U.S. - had been a life-transforming experience according to Höhn. The military in the occupied spaces was what the U.S. were not at the time: integrated. Contact zones in Germany provided experiences many of the Black soldiers had not made in the U.S. These first-hand experiences of integration became a very powerful narrative in the African American community back home.
In the third round of work in progress presentations Cedric Essi took up the questions of race and social change in his talk "Washington's Interracial Geneologies: From Thomas Jefferson to Barack Obama." Essi included the newest readings of Sally Hemmings in his analysis of the multiracial individual and family, mixed raced movements and the post-racial idea in the dominant popular discourse. Jonathan Plumb provided another transatlantic perspective in his dissertation project on "How the Artists Peter Weiss and Anselm Kiefer criticize Nazi Ideology." With Freud's "Melancholia and Mourning" (1915) Plumb examined how the ego can work through loss and traumatization and indicated the relevance of Anselm Kiefers' works for aesthetic pedagogy and political education.
The final three work in progress presentations started out with a descriptive perspective on contemporary political cultures and attempted to determine the outcomes with a more theoretical approach on the institutional level. Sebastian Dregger's talk focused on "The U.S. Supreme Court between Originalism and Living Constitution (Rehnquist and Roberts Courts 1986-2012)," Dorian Kantor presented a project titled "Politics as Law: Juridified Executive Unilateralism and Conservative Legal Movement" and Sarah Lisa Beringer analysed "The Flow of Trade between Nations."
During the following days the group was introduced to the work of the National Endowment of the Humanities and the research facilities of the Library of Congress by the staff of the John W. Kluge Center. Further keynotes by Max Friedman (American University), Barrett Watten (Wayne State University), and Donald Pease (Dartmouth College) plus the additional work in progress presentations made this summer academy a unique scholarly experience. The inspiring lectures, enthusiastic discussions and social networking have strengthened academic collaboration between German and U.S. researchers and the institutional ties of the GHI, American University, Wayne State University, the University of Erlangen-Nuremberg and the Bavarian American Academy.
Meike Zwingenberger (Bavarian American Academy) & Britta Waldschmidt-Nelson (GHI)